News

The following are some extracts of what the American judge Richard Posner explains in his blog. The idea is to expand copyright law at the time of making links to avoid the disappearance of print media.

As he says, "news, as well the other information found in newspapers, is available online for nothing, including at the websites of the newspapers themselves, who thus are giving away content."

"The economic downturn has doubtless accelerated the trend, but economic recovery is unlikely to reverse it. Many of the people who have switched under economic pressure to the free medium may find themselves as happy or happier and hence will not switch back when their financial condition improves."

"Online providers of news who are not affiliated with a newspaper can provide links to newspaper websites and paraphrase articles in newspapers, in neither case being required to compensate the newspaper."

"As newspaper revenues decline, newspaper content becomes thinner and thinner--but by the same token so does the linked or paraphrased newspaper content found in web sites that have no affiliation with a newspaper. If eventually newspapers vanish, online providers will have higher advertising revenues (because newspaper advertising will have disappeared) and may decide to charge for access to their online news, and so the critical question is whether online advertising revenues will defray the costly news-gathering expenses incurred at this time by newspapers."

"Imagine if the New York Times migrated entirely to the World Wide Web. Could it support, out of advertising and subscriber revenues, as large a news-gathering apparatus as it does today? This seems unlikely, because it is much easier to create a web site and free ride on other sites than to create a print newspaper and free ride on other print newspapers, in part because of the lag in print publication; what is staler than last week''s news."

"Expanding copyright law to bar online access to copyrighted materials without the copyright holder''s consent, or to bar linking to or paraphrasing copyrighted materials without the copyright holder''s consent, might be necessary to keep free riding on content financed by online newspapers from so impairing the incentive to create costly news-gathering operations that news services like Reuters and the Associated Press would become the only professional, nongovernmental sources of news and opinion."